An American Editor

March 2, 2011

Waiting for Common Sense — Not: The Agency 6

It used to be the Agency 5, now it’s the Agency 6 as Random House has caved and instituted agency pricing. This further changes my book-buying habits.

Let me start by saying that I am not outright opposed to the agency system. What I am opposed to — and appalled by — is the pricing. Granted that Agency 6 pricing clearly demonstrates lack of competition bordering on price collusion (Isn’t it amazing how similar the Agency 6 ebook pricing is across the board?), but that isn’t the primary problem I have: The primary problem is that the selected price points are extortionate considering the restrictions imposed in the license (and note that it is a changeable, revocable license). Compound this with Rupert Murdoch’s greedy ploy, through his HarperCollins subsidiary, aimed at libraries, the last bastion for education of the poor, and what you have is a devil’s cabal.

(In an interesting aside, Murdoch’s Fox News has been denied access to Canadian TV because of its lack of impartiality. See Regulators Reject Proposal That Would Bring Fox-Style News to Canada. Maybe that is why he feels he needs to bleed American libraries — to make up for lost revenues and bias outlets.)

In the past I have spent significant sums of money building both my hardcover library and my cache of ebooks. It wasn’t so long ago that I could be counted on to spend $5,000 or more in a year on such purchases. The Agency 5 put a big dent in that spending. I felt compelled — if not honor bound — not to buy books, p- or ebooks, published by the Agency 5 (except where necessary because I already had several volumes in an ongoing series). So I focused my purchases on self-published, indie presses, academic presses, and Random House books. The consequence was that my expenditures on new releases dropped by more than 50% last year.

With Random House now part of the Agency cabal, my habits will shift yet again. If I want a new release in hardcover, I will wait to buy it on the remainder or the used book market, when I know that neither one of the Agency 6 nor their author will receive any compensation. But my ebook buying will (and has been) change even more dramatically.

A good example of the change occurred yesterday. Yesterday, the long-awaited second volume in Patrick Rothfuss’ Kingkiller Chronicles (the first volume was The Name of the Wind; the second volume is The Wise Man’s Fear) was released. My previous practice was to buy both the hardcover and the ebook versions; not this time, however. This time I bought just the hardcover because of the agency pricing (the ebook is virtually the same price as the hardcover and no ebookseller can sell it for a price lower than $14.99, which is exorbitant).

That is but one example. Increasingly, I am only “buying” free ebooks and ebooks that cost $2.99 or less, and those I am buying from Smashwords. The reason I buy from Smashwords is that most authors let you sample their work before you buy, some offering up to 75% of the ebook as a free sample. I admit that in the case of the free ebooks I don’t sample them, I simply download those that seem interesting, but for those that do cost some money, I generally read a portion of the sample before buying.

At Smashwords I discovered several self-publishing authors whose works are excellent. Granted they do not have the cachet of a Stephen King, J.D. Robb, or Robin Hobb, but they do know how to write a compelling story. A good example is Safina Desforges’ Sugar & Spice, a 99¢ mystery/thriller that compares well to any P.D. James novel.

The point is that the setting of exorbitant pricing by the Agency 6 has compelled me to look elsewhere for book purchases. Money that I previously spent supporting the traditional publishers is now going elsewhere — and it is costing me less yet giving me comparable enjoyment.

Yet there is one more thing that has to be said about the agency system. Currently, it is limited to ebooks. But that doesn’t make a lot of sense to me over the long run.

Under the more traditional wholesale system, the publisher sets a retail price for a book and the bookseller pays to the publisher approximately 50% of that wholesale price for each copy sold, regardless of the price that the consumer pays. (Yes, there are more wrinkles in the system, but I’m simplifying it for this discussion.) This is how it started with ebooks. The excuse for going to the agency system where the publisher sets the retail price below which no ebook can be sold and which pays the bookseller a fee for each sale was that low ebook pricing devalued the book and its content.

If that is a valid and sustainable argument, how does low pricing of the hardcover not devalue the book and its contents, too? Logically, there can be no difference. After all, a book is bought for its content, not for its package, and supposedly the content of the p- and ebooks are identical.

What this means to me is that we are the road to a major shakeup in the book industry. I think the agency system is only beginning with ebooks and will either have to be abandoned for ebooks or spread to pbooks. Although agency pricing has not been a big win so far, spreading it to pbooks could solve a major problem for publishers — the problem of returns, which would also solve the problem of excessive book print runs and remainders, and minimize the secondary market.

With the Agency 6 controlling more than half the publishing market overall and probably 75% or greater of the nonfiction market, the path they take could well become — and quickly — the path that smaller publishers take. The bulwark against the spread of agency pricing is the self-publishing market, but that market has to find ways of uniformly increasing its standards before it will supplant the traditional publishers.

In the end, it is clear that the Agency 6 lack common sense. At the same time that one or more of the Agency 6 publishers expects ebooks to grow to as much as 20% of all book sales in 2011, they try to thwart the one avenue of growth by imposing extortionate prices and limiting competition. Simultaneously, they allow the wholesale model to continue for pbooks, thereby devaluing their product and its content. Some day they will get it together; unfortunately, when that day comes, I expect it will not be to the consumer’s advantage.

In the meantime, I’ve changed my buying habits significantly and may well represent an unrecoverable customer loss for the Agency 6.



  1. Hardcover books have always been a last resort for me. With money short and space even shorter, most of my library is paperback and secondhand. I’ll always love, buy, and read print books, but ebooks solve the problem of space and, often, of money. I’ll be putting my first book out soon, as a Smashwords ebook, and my blog is set up partly to promote Smashwords and its authors. Eventually, I believe, HarperCollins and its ilk will be irrelevant because authors will learn to make their books available wherever there are readers, including public libraries.


    Comment by Catana — March 2, 2011 @ 9:43 am | Reply

  2. […] by Rich Adin […]


    Pingback by Waiting for Common Sense — Not: The Agency 6 | The Digital Reader — March 2, 2011 @ 10:36 am | Reply

  3. I will certainly be looking at the publisher of the book and if it belongs to one of the Agency 6, I will probably decline to buy it (either pbook or ebook) – unless it is something I really really have to have!

    My Kindle has changed my buying habits. It is too hard to graze through the offerings like in a bookstore, where I can wander as I please. I usually have a list of 3-4 books and walk out with 20. Now I just download the original 3-4. This is certainly going to save me money in the long run and hurt the brick & mortar stores especially if more people do this.

    My book buying days of $500 per month are now gone!


    Comment by Jackie — March 2, 2011 @ 11:18 am | Reply

  4. I’ve had a Kindle for 14 months, and in that time, I have bought over 1400 books. I’m the kind of customer that publishers should be wooing (and, in case they don’t get it yet — and they don’t — with agency pricing, I AM their customer). The last thing these people should be doing is giving me a reason to buy on the used book market, but I am not going to pay extortionate prices for one-time reads or backlist books. Why should I pay $15.99 plus tax for the new Grisham in October when I need only wait a month to pick up a used copy for $5.00? Why should I pay $14.99 plus tax for books that Random House thought so little of that they went out of print? And why should I EVER pay $19.99 plus tax for something I can pick up on the used market for 25% of that? (These aren’t made-up examples; they’re from my Amazon wish list.) The only way these people will learn is through declining sales. Then they may wake up and find that the end customer that they ignored is in charge.


    Comment by Linda Furlet — March 2, 2011 @ 1:06 pm | Reply

  5. Since I switched to ebooks, I started keeping track of how much I spend on ebooks. Last year I spent 30% less than the previous two years. I’m buying less books because of agency pricing. I also bought a Sony reader so I could download books from my local library. Since I’ve noticed that Random house is raising prices, I’m sure that trend will continue. I’ll be using the library more, and trying new authors.


    Comment by Diane — March 2, 2011 @ 1:48 pm | Reply

  6. I read about a hundred books a year split half and half between fiction and non-fiction. Living in west Texas means that even the hard back books I buy are purchased through the internet. E-books and Amazon have made a huge difference in my ability to get books. I now have many choices for selecting books.

    My view of a fair price for a widely read book is below $10.00. If there is a book I would like to read that is above that price, I use to track the price. I can do this because I have over a hundred books on my “to be read” list that are in my price range and I no longer need need to be in any hurry to buy a specific book.

    Before e-books, I would wait for the paper back to come out unless the book really qualified as a keep-forever book. One big change I have seen with the Agency books is before the agency model, you could always count on the e-book prices to track the cheapest price for a book. When the paperback version came out the e-book price would drop to correspond to the new price.

    Price adjustments on the e-book pricing can no longer be counted on to drop with the paperback release. Where is the retailing sense when a paperback is selling for $9.00 and the corresponding e-book is still at $14.95? After all, I really don’t own an e-book. I can’t resell it, give it away or lend it to a friend.

    At least the EU is now looking into price fixing in the agency model. Random House in England is NOT going to the agency model yet.


    Comment by Joe J. — March 3, 2011 @ 9:16 am | Reply

  7. You may want to keep an eye on my friend (novelist, agent, editor, and probably a lot of other roles) Allan Guthrie’s EBooks That Sell blog: He profiles books you’ve never heard of that have sold in phenomenal quantities as e-books.

    For me, I’ll stick with paperbacks. If I lose one, I can afford to replace it. When I’ve read one, I can resell it or give it away. It can’t be revoked or get lost in a cloud.


    Comment by Joy Matkowski — March 3, 2011 @ 3:03 pm | Reply

  8. […] House instituted agency […]


    Pingback by Stumbling Over Chaos :: Linkity, now with knitting finished object! — March 4, 2011 @ 3:02 am | Reply

  9. Hi,

    I just happened to stumble across this post.

    Firstly, may I say “thank you” to the writer of it for recommending my book, Sugar & Spice. It has just become a bestseller in the UK Amazon Store, ousting the likes of Stieg Larsson and Stephen Leather from their comfy spots in the top ten!

    Secondly, how true!

    As an indie author, and as others have commented, we are purposely keeping our prices low, as the cost to us is relatively low and should be passed onto the reader (IMHO).

    The cost to the environment is also greatly reduced.

    I am not adverse to DTP (Dead Tree Publishing) at all, but the price of ebooks by some of the so-called ‘bestsellers’ is ludicrous! There are famous writers in the top ten now that I will never read again, solely due to the fact that they (or their publishing house) requires £8.99 for a book that cost almost NOTHING to make available on Kindle.

    I may or may not end up publishing the traditional way and the pricing may be taken out of my hands, but rest assured, whilst I am in control of it, you will not see one of Saffina Desforge’s books for sale for more than a very reasonable and realistic amount.

    There is no WAY we would be selling 12,000 books a month (as we are now) at £8.99 – just look at the chart for proof of that!

    Thanks again!

    Saffina Desforges

    PS. You can get S&S here:


    Comment by Saffina Desforges — March 23, 2011 @ 4:19 pm | Reply

  10. Thanks for Sharing this Beautiful information…

    E-books Tunnel


    Comment by ghazi1 — September 4, 2011 @ 9:35 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: