An American Editor

April 13, 2011

Frustration in eBookville: Will There Be a Rubicon for Publishers?

I’m one frustrated ebooker! I recently purchased several books in hardcover (The Eichmann Trial by Deborah E. Lipstadt and Bismarck: A Life by Jonathan Steinberg), which is (supposedly) what the publishers prefer I do. But although I bought hardcover versions for my library, I would like to do the actual reading on my Sony Reader.

I already own (and read years ago) Hannah Arendt’s 1963 book on the Eichmann trial, Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil, and I would like to read it again but this time as an ebook. I am particularly interested in comparing the Arendt’s contemporaneous account (who also attended the trial) with Lipstadt’s hindsight account. The reviews of Lipstadt’s book indicate she comes to a conclusion opposite from Arendt regarding Eichmann’s role in the Holocaust.

All three books are available as ebooks. One would think, then that the problem is solved. Just buy the ebooks. Alas, it isn’t solved because of the exorbitant ebook pricing.

I purchased The Eichmann Trial for $16.20; the ebook costs $12.99. I purchased Bismarck: A Life for $21.25; the ebook costs $14.97. Arendt’s Eichmann in Jerusalem was originally published in hardcover in 1963 (I own a first edition of the book). In 2006, Penguin released a paperback version. I can buy the paperback today for $10.98, but the ebook costs $12.99. Based on the ebook price, one would think Arendt’s book had been released for the first time yesterday, not that it is nearly 50 years since its publication!

The publishers of these books are playing a dangerous game. It is readers like me, that is, readers who want both hardcover and ebook versions of a book, that publishers and authors should be trying to find ways to accommodate. We are interested in buying a book twice.

Alas, it appears that neither the publishers nor the authors are able to wrap their heads around the concept of a decent package price. It is certainly obvious that publishers are fixated on a single remedy to cure all ills, with that remedy being high ebook pricing — even on a book first published 48 years ago. What happened to the promise of lower prices the further away from the initial hardcover release we are? How much farther away than 48 years do we need to be?

As it stands now, the ebook pricing scheme is forcing me to consider the darknet route for the ebooks. Truthfully, I’m not sure that I’d even consider, in this instance, darknetting as piracy, as I bought the version the publishers wanted me to buy — the hardcover version; after all, preserving hardcover sales was/is the rationale for high ebook pricing.

What the publishers should be doing is thinking up schemes to entice me to buy both the hardcover and ebook versions. The first step to accomplishing this is to come up with a realistic ebook price when the hardcover has already been purchased or as a package price at the time of the hardcover purchase. This latter approach would work easily.

Give me the option to buy the hardcover alone, the ebook alone, or the hardcover-plus-ebook combination. In the combination package, charge me $5 more than the hardcover alone. Because I value having hardcovers in my permanent collection but want the pleasure and ease of reading the book on my Sony Reader, I, for one, would readily pay a $5 premium for the package. Publishers should learn from the movie companies, which increasingly are offering DVDs in two packages: DVD alone and a combination of DVD plus Blu-Ray, with the combination package costing only a few dollars more.

With all their complaints about piracy and the threat the darknet raises to their existence, the reality is that publishers are their own worst enemy because they refuse to address honestly what the marketplace wants. Instead of complaining about their problems and doing nothing productive to solve them, publishers should be devising creative solutions to those problems — and packaging the hardcover and the ebook together, although not a final solution, is one interim solution that would increase sales and revenues yet preserve the hardcover that publishers seem to be focused on preserving.

If publishers do not take such steps, they will have met their own Rubicon. They will turn ebookers like me into darknetters, the opposite of what publishers want and need to happen. It is time for publishers to meet head on the challenges of the eBook Age and not continue to try to hide them beneath the carpet.


  1. With the sale of a DVD/Blu-ray movie, sometimes a digital copy is included that you can download onto your computer. I’m thinking of recent releases like “The Fighter” and”Despicable Me.” It seems odd and stupid that something similar (a combo pack of hardcover/ebook or softcover/ebook) can’t be worked out with book releases.


    Comment by richhell — April 13, 2011 @ 6:06 am | Reply

  2. […] reposted with permission from An American Editor […]


    Pingback by Frustration in eBookville: Will There Be a Rubicon for Publishers? | The Digital Reader — April 13, 2011 @ 6:07 am | Reply

  3. I am not familiar with the word “darknet” but I have the same opinion about the hight cost of some e-books. I recently purchased e-books for my Kindle – and found that the paperback at $7.99 and the ebook at $7.99. The only reason I went the e-book route is that I have no more room for paperbacks. If I had used my discount cards, I could have saved some pennies but paid then paid sales tax and used my car to go to the bookstore. With gas at $4.30 where I live, that made more sense. But still, the same price? How ridiculous!!!!!


    Comment by Jackie — April 13, 2011 @ 2:47 pm | Reply

  4. OR Books at already offers a print version plus ebook version package. In fact the ebook comes as a Zip file containing a folder for Mac users and a folder for Windows users. In the folder for Windows are ePub, mobi, prc, and pdf versions of the book.

    I strongly recommend the latest one I bought: ‘Tweets from Tahrir’ which is a compilation of tweets and photographs covering the recent revolution which brought down Mubarak.

    Regards, Alex


    Comment by Alex Bell — April 14, 2011 @ 1:34 am | Reply

    • Thanks for the tip about OR Books. I have added its website to my Favorites list for ebooks. What OR Books demnstrates is that it isn’t so difficult to give readers reasonable purchase options.


      Comment by americaneditor — April 14, 2011 @ 4:21 am | Reply

  5. […] Frustration in eBookville: Will There Be a Rubicon for Publishers? « An American Editor A great piece where the author rediscovers the joys of her local public library. Always nice to see some good things being written about us. Not everything is doom and gloom. […]


    Pingback by Friday Reads – Pollen Edition « Matt Phillips — April 15, 2011 @ 7:48 am | Reply

  6. I agree with everything you say. And the mulitfaceted shortcomings of type quality bothers me. At first I blamed the hardware. I now know better – the publishers are to blame.


    Comment by Paul Wigmore — April 17, 2011 @ 11:30 am | Reply

  7. I don’t think I would usually want both a hardcover and ebook version, although if there were deals like that it would get me to buy several books (mostly non-fiction) that I currently can’t decide upon which format to buy (i.e. The Information by James Gleick).

    I have found the price of many ebooks too high. For example I wanted to read Sweet Thursday by John Steinbeck, and I thought an ebook would be great. Penguin sells the ebook for $12.99! Steinbeck is dead, for heaven’s sake. As another example, I downloaded the ebook Kindle sample of a travel memoir, which unsurprisingly had maps at the beginning. However, the maps were set at such a low resolution, they were clear only at a 1 x 2 inch size on my iPad screen, which made the type too small to read (in the actual printed book, the maps are each the size of a trade paper page). Yet the publisher wanted $11.99 for the ebook.

    I have wondered how to meaningfully bring my customer dissatisfaction to the attention of the publishing industry. When the ebook is priced too high and/or the quality of the production is poor, especially to the point of non-functionality, I will buy the paper copy as a used book. That is perfectly legal, and yet the publisher gets nothing. Of course, the author also suffers. I have decided to write to the publishers and author each time I do this (so far twice) and let them know why I chose to buy a used paper copy of a book rather than the ebook. It is a small drop in the ocean, although I buy over 100 books a year, and I would like to buy the majority as ebooks, but it is a start.


    Comment by Brenda — April 29, 2011 @ 4:54 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: